Counterfeit Repentance — by Thomas Watson, 1668

COUNTERFEITS of Repentance (from Thomas Watson’s The Doctrine of Repentance, Puritan Paperbacks series) —

To discover what true repentance is, I shall first show what it is not. There are several counterfeits of repentance, which might occasion that saying of Augustine that “repentance damns many”. He meant a false repentance; a person may delude himself with counterfeit repentance:

1) The first counterfeit of repentance, is LEGAL TERROR. A man has gone on long in sin. At last God arrests him, shows him what desperate hazard he has run — and he is filled with anguish. But after a while, the tempest of conscience is blown over, and he is quiet. Then he concludes that he is a true penitent because he has felt some bitterness in sin. Do not be deceived! This is not true repentance! Both Ahab and Judas had great trouble of mind. It is one thing to be a terrified sinner — and another to be a repenting sinner. Sense of guilt is enough to breed terror in the conscience. Only infusion of divine grace, breeds true repentance. If pain and trouble were sufficient to repentance, then the damned in hell should be most penitent, for they are most in anguish. “Men gnawed their tongues in agony and cursed the God of heaven because of their pains and their sores, but they refused to repent of what they had done!” Revelation 16:10-11. Repentance depends upon a change of heart. There may be terror — yet with no change of heart. “I preached that they should repent and turn to God and prove their repentance by their deeds.” Acts 26:20.

2) Another counterfeit about repentance, is RESOLUTION AGAINST SIN. A person may purpose and make vows — yet be no penitent. “You said, I will not transgress (Jer. 2:20). Here was a good resolution. But see what follows: “but still you would not obey me. On every hill and under every green tree, you have prostituted yourselves by bowing down to idols!” Notwithstanding her solemn engagements, they played fast and loose with God — and ran after their idols! We see by experience what protestations against sin, a person will make when he is on his sick-bed, if God should recover him again. Yet if that person does recover — he is as bad as ever. He shows his old heart in a new temptation. Resolutions against sin may arise:

(1) From present extremity; not because sin is sinful — but because it is painful. This kind of resolution will vanish.

(2) From fear of future evil, an apprehension of death and hell. “I looked, and there before me was a pale horse! Its rider was named Death, and Hell was following close behind him!” (Rev. 6:8). What will a sinner not do — what vows will he not make — when he knows he must die and stand before the God in judgment? Self-love raises a sickbed repentance. But if he recovers — the love of sin will prevail against it. Trust not to a such passionate resolution; it is raised in a storm — and will die in a calm!

3) The third counterfeit about repentance, is the leaving of many sinful ways. It is a great matter, I confess, to leave sin. So dear is sin to a man — that he will rather part with a child than with a lust! “Shall I give the fruit of my body — for the sin of my soul?” (Micah 6:7). Sin may be parted with — yet without repentance.

(1) A man may part with some sins and keep others. Herod reformed many things which were amiss — but could not leave his beloved Herodias.

2) An old sin may be left in order to entertain a new sin — as you get rid an old servant to take another. This is to exchange a sin. Sin may be exchangedand the heart remained unchanged. He who was a profligate in his youth, turns to be a miser in his old age. A slave is sold to a Jew; the Jew sells him to a Turk. Here the master is changed — but he is a slave still. So a man moves from one vice to another — but remains an unrepentant sinner still.

(3) A sin may be left not so much from strength of grace — as from reasons of prudence. A man sees that though such a sin is for his pleasure — yet it is not for his best interest. It will eclipse his credit, harm his health, or impair his estate. Therefore, for prudential reasons, he dismisses it. But true leaving of sin, is when the acts of sin cease from a principle of grace infused into the soul — as the air ceases to be dark from the infusion of light.  [Emphasis original.]

[April 2, 2023: Editors’ notes:

—For some comments made prior to April 2, 2023 that quoted from the post, the text in the comment that was quoted from the post might no longer be an exact match.
—For some comments made prior to April 2, 2023 that quoted from the post, the text in the comment that was quoted from the post might no longer be found in the post.
If you would like to compare the text in the comments made prior to April 2, 2023 that quoted from the post to the post as it is now (April 2, 2023), click here [Internet Archive link] for the most recent Internet Archive copy of the post.]


UPDATE Sept 2021: I have come to believe that Jeff Crippen does not practise what he preaches. He vilely persecuted an abuse victim and spiritually abused many other people in the Tillamook congregation. Go here to read the evidence. Jeff has not gone to the people that he spiritually and emotionally abused. He has not apologised to them, let alone asked for their forgiveness.

4 thoughts on “Counterfeit Repentance — by Thomas Watson, 1668”

  1. This is really good.

    It does, however, remind me of a question I used to ask years ago when I first started dating him. I began to question the genuineness of his walk with Christ because something didn’t seem to add up. Yet I could not ever adequately address the question of why the grace of God, as mentioned in the above post, came to me to lead me to repentance and yet not to him? If it is of grace, it is not of works. I knew I wasn’t any more “holy” or “worthy” or “better” than he was, so why the difference? I did not, and still do not, doubt his sincere desire to change and walk with Christ, yet that alone is not repentance. Only the grace of God “infused into the soul” eradicates sin and brings about real repentance. It happened for me, but not for him. Neither of us deserved it. That I can’t quite comprehend — why one, and not the other, though both should desire it and neither qualifies for it? The answer that one can only receive it in humility is perhaps the most satisfactory answer, although it implies that I was more humble, which in itself is a thought rooted in religious pride.

  2. Anonymous – absolutely. You have it “figured out” just about as far as it can be. Jacob I loved, Esau I hated — it is not because of man who does, but of God who chooses. One for the glory of His grace, the other for the glory of His holy justice. At the same time, the Bible holds Esau accountable, as God holds all who reject Christ accountable. Man does indeed have free choice, but free choice is simply the ability to choose what we truly desire. The sinner truly does not desire God and freely chooses to reject Him. We are saved in Christ only because of the mighty invasion of our hearts by the Spirit of God. He chooses whom He chooses, and not because of anything in us that merits His choice of us. Malachi 1:1-5; Romans 9; Ephesians 1-2.

  3. This is fantastic. How grateful I am to Thomas Watson and the Puritans!

    I can think of people who are examples of the things Watson delineates. One gave up his favorite sin-buddy (alcohol) for quite some time, for reasons of prudence related to his health. Another made repeated vows to forswear a particularly beloved sin, but each vow only lasted about two days before he fell again. Another lay for weeks on his death bed fearing Hell, and in terror confessed to a priest, but died in his terror. And I myself, before I became a Christian, swapped my enslavement from one sin to another: I replaced bulimia with illicit drug abuse and promiscuity, then later I gave them up and switched back to bulimia as my primary addiction.

    Oh the benevolent mercies of God, to drag me out of that mire!

Leave a comment. It's ok to use a made up name (e.g Anon37). For safety tips read 'New Users Info' (top menu). Tick the box if you want to be notified of new comments.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.